I have caught the same trout before quite a few times. A couple years back my friend Jim caught the below trout.
I did a quick measurement and she taped 19 inches. Very respectable for such a tiny stream.
Almost a year to the date later I fished it with an acquaintance named Bruce.
He caught the same fish from the same hole. This time it taped 21 inches.
Went after her the next year and year after and nobody was home.